The Coded Gaze: Why UX Must Look Beyond the Mirror

As a UX design researcher with a decade and a half dedicated to digital strategy and design, I’ve seen countless trends come and go. But every so often, a piece of work emerges that doesn’t just capture a moment—it rewrites the playbook entirely. Joy Buolamwini’s Unmasking AI is one such book. It is a powerful, deeply personal narrative that serves as a critical call to action for our profession. This is a must-read for anyone who believes, as I do, that our role is to build a truly universal and equitable digital world.

When a White Mask Made Me Visible

The central concept of the “coded gaze” originates from a profoundly personal anecdote. Buolamwini, as a graduate student at MIT, discovered that the face-tracking software for her project consistently failed to detect her (black) face. Yet, in a moment of frustration, the system instantly recognized her when she held a plain white mask in front of her. This technical failure was a revelation: the systems were designed with an inherent bias, reflecting the priorities and prejudices of those with the power to create the technology. This made me realize that design defaults are never neutral; they are a direct reflection of a society’s power structures, even when unintentional.

Auditing for Algorithmic Injustice

Moving beyond a single anecdote, Buolamwini transformed her personal frustration into groundbreaking academic research. Her “Gender Shades” study meticulously audited AI systems from giants like IBM, Microsoft, and a Chinese company, revealing a startling truth: the high-level accuracy rates touted by these firms masked severe performance disparities. By using an intersectional analysis, she found that these systems had error rates of up to 34.4% between lighter-skinned males and darker-skinned females. This work exposed the myth of objective technology and proved that the “gold standard” datasets used for training were, in fact, “fool’s gold” due to their heavy bias toward what she termed “pale male” faces.

From Code to Conscience: A New Design Brief

Buolamwini’s journey is a powerful roadmap for every designer. She demonstrates how to move from being a “maker” to becoming a passionate “advocate.” The book is a compelling call for “algorithmic justice”, pushing us to look beyond a product’s functionality and confront its social and ethical implications. Her work with Brooklyn tenants fighting facial recognition and her testimony before the U.S. Congress serve as potent examples of how designers can and must translate their technical knowledge into tangible, real-world action. Our new design brief is clear: we must design for transparency, oversight, and accountability, ensuring that our work is guided by a collective conscience, not a coded gaze.

Respond to The Coded Gaze: Why UX Must Look Beyond the Mirror

Leave a comment